I’ll make this quick. I think James “D” Vanderbeek and Nettie Ward Vanderbeek only had two children. Shocking, I know…
When I recently went to FamilySearch.org/tree, I found four children listed for James and Nettie:
- James Lawrence Vanderbeek (1892)
- Ruth Vanderhoek (1894) suspect!
- Stuart Ward Vanderbeek (1895)
- James L. Vanderhoek (1908) suspect!
Here’s why I think there are really only two children, James (1892) and Stuart (1895). I remembered that the census records often ask the mothers how many children they had given birth to and how many were alive:
Notice the little “1” and the “1” next to it? This mother claimed to have given birth once and the child was still alive.
So here is Nettie’s line (along with her two boys) in the 1910 US Census. Here husband is listed on the previous census page, so you won’t see him here:
Notice, all the way on the right hand side, the little “2’s”? Two births, two living children. It is the same on the 1900 Census.
So, I’ll do a little more work..check birth records, etc., but I really can’t find anything remotely close to a Ruth or James L. Vanderhoek…so, they’re probably on the verge of getting cut…